If you searched Superstar Sourcing for Senior Customer Service Representative (with 2 additional requirements) on January 3, 2026 you'd find 437 great candidates

R**** S****

Agent at State Farm Insurance Agency

Excellent fit - senior insurance professional with significant time as both an agent and a claims manager. State Farm Agent → Claims Team Manager at State Farm, 30 years total experience. Excellent.

A**** K****

Assistant Vice President Casualty Claims/ Team Leader

This professional has extensive experience leading claims operations and has senior-level tenure within the insurance space. Ex-State Farm → The Wright Insurance Group, 34 years experience, AVP Casualty Claims/Team Leader. Strong.

J**** J****

Casualty Evaluator at CSAA

This professional has deep, specific recent experience in insurance claims adjustment and is geographically located correctly. CSAA Casualty Specialist → Progressive Adjuster (several roles), 12 years experience. Excellent.

S**** D****

Insurance Professional

This candidate looks very strong, having spent significant time in a combined customer service and claims management role within the insurance sector. MetLife (14yr 8mo) as C/S & Claims Manager. Excellent.

C**** G****

Client Services Manager at Gallagher

This candidate is a Client Services Manager in insurance who explicitly manages client relationships and operations, aligning very well with the core requirements, although the title is Manager, not CSR. Gallagher → HUB International, extensive client/broker interaction. Excellent.

E**** C****

Insurance Professional

Very strong background focusing on claims and insurance for 18 years, matching the senior and claims aspects perfectly, though title is 'assistant'. State Farm senior claim assistant for 18 years. Strong.

S**** A****

Insurance Professional

This candidate is highly relevant with extensive senior-level experience in managing insurance claims, though the title isn't CSR. Experienced senior manager focusing on complex commercial claims for 24+ years. Farmers Ins. → GEICO (management, claims). Ended up in management, less direct CSR. Strong.

N**** C****

Insurance Professional

Strong contender with direct Senior CSR experience in insurance claims and long tenure in the industry, perfectly located. Claims Specialist → Senior Customer Service Representative (Insurance) for 9+ years total in claims/CSR roles, 35 years experience. Excellent.

M**** E****

Senior Account Manager

This candidate is a senior professional with decades in the insurance industry, including leadership/account management, likely encompassing client relations, though specific claims handling isn't highlighted in the summary. Senior Account Manager @ Prince Associates (16.2 yrs) → CPCU Instructor @ Hofstra (9 yrs) → Operations Manager @ AutoOne Insurance (7 yrs). Excellent.

T**** H****

Experienced Senior Claims Advocate | Expert in Risk Management & Client Relations | Promoting Fair and Efficient Claims Resolution

This candidate is an excellent match, explicitly stating Senior Claims Advocate experience, robust claims management, and client relations, meeting the senior level requirement and industry fit. Senior Claims Advocate (HUB Int'l/Global Coverage) → Claims & Ops Manager, certified (CPCU, AIC, API). Excellent.

J**** P****

Senior Account Analyst at Liberty Mutual Insurance

Excellent match combining senior-level tenure, explicit insurance claims adjuster/specialist roles, and strong relationship building history, all within commuting distance. Liberty Mutual → GEICO Adjuster → Liberty Mutual Senior Analyst. Excellent.

A**** J****

Insurance Specialist at GEICO

This candidate has significant tenure at GEICO, specifically coaching, handling claims reports, managing liability, and dealing with injured claimants, fitting the seniority and claims need well, though client relationship management is inferred through interaction. GEICO career progression: Assistant Manager → Specialist → Coach/Claims handling, 22+ years total experience. Excellent.

G**** K***

Senior Account Executive at MagnaCare

Strong senior candidate with direct insurance claims and extensive client-facing account management experience right in the service area. Senior Account Executive → AVP Sales/Account Mgmt → Claims Editor, 39 years exp, Manhattan College. Excellent.

A**** S****

This candidate has extensive, long-tenured experience (7+ years) specifically in liability claims handling for major insurers, fitting the seniority requirement, and demonstrating excellent customer interaction (providing outstanding customer experience). Experience: Liability Claims at Allstate (7.5 yrs) → AVP Claims Exec. Manager level, 13+ years total experience. Excellent.

L**** R****

Experienced BI Claims Adjuster

Excellent fit for the insurance claims and seniority requirements, with direct prior experience in a Customer Service Representative role at GEICO. Experienced BI Adjuster handling claims, liability, and negotiations; previously CSR at GEICO for 2+ years. GEICO (CSR/Claims Adjuster) → Nat'l General → Current. Strong seniority in claims field. Excellent.

B**** M****

Claims Customer Service at Geico Insurance Company

Perfectly blends high-level customer service experience within the insurance industry, including claims, and explicitly mentions maintaining great client relationships across 45 years of experience. GEICO Claims CS → Allstate Agent → Supervisor/Manager roles. Excellent.

B*** H****

Long tenure (20+ years) as a General Claims Manager in a dedicated Health Insurance Office, strongly matching seniority, industry, and claims experience, although CRM needs inference. General Claims Manager @ Cigna Healthcare (20.2 yrs). Strong.

R**** C****

No headline please

Strong match due to direct claims experience and proximity, though the most recent role listed is technical claims rather than relationship management. Travelers Claims → GEICO Claims (11+ years in claims roles) → High School Teacher. Strong.

B**** G****

Licensed Insurance Agent/Office Manager at Allstate

This candidate looks very relevant as a customer service and sales leader in the insurance space with strong client focus. Allstate Agent/Office Manager → Client advisor/sales, 14+ years total experience, specialized in P&C/NFIP. Excellent.

A**** T****

Operations Manager at Travelers

Excellent fit with direct insurance claims adjusting experience and sufficient tenure in the industry, plus location matches perfectly. Property Claims Adjuster (Allstate) → Ops Leader → Operations Manager (Travelers), 15 yrs exp. Excellent.

P**** E****

Experienced Insurance Specialist

Excellent fit, includes multiple documented Customer Service Representative roles, claims examiner experience, and is senior/experienced within the insurance industry. GEICO CSR (3yr 5mo) → Claims Examiner (1yr 9mo) → GEICO CSR (1yr 11mo). Matches CSR, Senior level (total 13+ years exp), Claims, and Industry. CRM is strongly implied by CSR/retention focus.

G**** T****

Principal Managing Partner at Eli Cohen Insurance Agency

Strong insurance industry background focused on account management, policy analysis, and client interaction, but doesn't explicitly list 'Customer Service Representative' title or 'claims experience'. Ex-Eli Cohen Agency → Tallegra Risk Services → Allstate → Nationwide, 11+ years experience. Strong.

D*** P***

Telephone Claims Representative/No Fault Examiner at GEICO

This candidate has extensive background as a Claims Representative, fitting the insurance claims and industry criteria well, but the CSR and Senior level aspects are partial fits based on the title. Claims Rep → GEICO 14+ years, AAS degree. Strong.

K*** B****

Claims Coordinator

Excellent fit for insurance claims experience and seniority, but the title is Claims Coordinator/Analyst rather than Customer Service Representative, although high operational relevance exists. LIBERTY Dental Plan Claims roles (6+ years) → Analyst. Strong.

L**** R****

Supervisor Customer Service at Enzo Clinical Labs

This supervisor role involves managing a CSR team, handling insurance settlement of claims, and dealing with upper management, achieving seniority in a tangential customer service structure within a potentially relevant sector. Supervisor CSR → CSR Supervisor, 5 years 11 months experience. Strong.

L**** P****

Claims Supervisor at GEICO

Excellent fit for experience related to insurance claims and senior level supervisory experience within the insurance industry, though the role is Supervisor, not CSR, and CRM isn't explicitly listed. Claims Supervisor at GEICO for 14+ years, strong claims history. Strong.

K**** S****

Litigation Claims Representative with National General

Excellent match on insurance claims experience and senior tenure directly supporting the core job requirements, though the title used is 'Representative' or 'Adjuster'. Baldwin, NY → GEICO/Farmers/National General (19+ yrs claims/litigation). Specialist.

N**** W****

Liability Claims Examiner | MBA, AIC

Strong background in claims handling and management within the insurance industry, coupled with demonstrated customer service aptitude, although the most recent role was in finance/accounts payable. Claims Examiner/Manager (3+ yrs) → Accounts Payable (2 yrs) → 12+ yrs total experience, MBA. Strong.

S**** W****

Claims Adjuster at York Risk Services Group

This candidate has excellent recent claims experience in the insurance industry and is senior level, scoring high despite lacking explicit CSR or client relationship titles. Claims Adjuster → Hempstead NY. Strong.

J*** C****

This candidate has extensive, recent, and direct experience as a claims adjuster/rep within the insurance industry, meeting all core requirements except the specific CSR title, although adjuster roles are closely related. Claims Adjuster/Rep at Plymouth Rock & GEICO (7+ years total, entirely claims focused). Strong.