If you searched Superstar Sourcing for Insurance Claims Case Manager (with 3 additional requirements) on January 3, 2026 you'd find 220 great candidates

M*** C****

PI Case Manager | Notary Public

This candidate has recent direct PI Law Firm experience, including requesting medical records for demand packages, making this a very strong match, though explicit VA experience is missing. Ricci Law Firm Injury Lawyers (Case Manager/Legal Reception) → administrative support roles. Strong.

K**** S****

This attorney has direct experience representing injured parties (plaintiff work) and is located in Virginia, fitting most qualitative requirements, although the titles are Attorney/Manager rather than Case Manager. Attorney at Monge & Associates (Representing injured parties) → Litigation Attorney Manager at Christina Pendleton & Associates. Strong.

C**** A****

Claims QA Specialist

Excellent experience overlap with 22 years in personal injury, including paralegal roles at plaintiff firms and injury examiner roles. Currently located in Virginia. National Interstate Claims QA → Marks & Harrison PI Paralegal → Joel Bieber Firm PI Paralegal, 26 years total experience. Excellent.

S**** C****

Patient Advocate at Private Investor and Consultant

Strongest candidate with recent direct experience as a paralegal handling plaintiff personal injury cases, including thorough medical record review, and is located in Virginia. Paralegal (PI plaintiff) → Patient Advocate. Strong.

S**** V****

Case Manager

This candidate has direct, recent Personal Injury Case Manager experience and is located in Virginia, but lacks clear direct evidence of medical records review or a plaintiff firm background, although paralegal support is listed. Personal Injury Case Manager (Monge & Associates) → Litigation Paralegal (Tavss Fletcher Maiden & Reed). Strong overall fit, but PI firm/Medical Review specific info is partial. Strong.

L**** S****

Claims Quality Assurance Consultant

Strong profile demonstrating PI Case Manager experience at a known PI firm, relevant medical review skills, and experience negotiating PI claims, though location is outside VA boundary. Allstate → Morgan & Morgan, P.A. → Liberty Mutual. Strong.

J**** P****

Virginia Personal Injury Attorney for Victims of Trucking and Car Accidents - Skilled at Beating Insurance Companies

This attorney has nearly 25 years representing personal injury victims, including working against insurance companies, and is based in Virginia, though the role is for management/review, not strictly attorney work. Parrish Law Firm (Attorney/Owner) → Previous roles in insurance defense/trial law. Strong.

A*** D****

Plaintiff’s Attorney | Products Liability & Medical Malpractice

This candidate is a Plaintiff's Attorney specializing in Personal Injury (including motor vehicle/medical malpractice) and certainly deals with medical records and litigation, providing strong transferable skills, though the job isn't explicitly legal counsel. Plaintiff's attorney focused on PI/Med Mal → defense litigation → insurance sales/ops. Strong.

H**** S****

Case Manager

This professional has direct personal injury case management experience with explicit mention of coordinating with attorneys and conducting case reviews, but is based in North Carolina and lacks explicit medical records review mention. PI Case Manager at Kellum Law Firm (plaintiff side focus) → Care Manager. Strong.

S**** O****

Claims Specialist at Chubb

Strong background in personal injury claims, including work in a law firm setting, though current role is broader insurance claims. Has PI experience and prior law firm work. Career: Law firm (PI, litigation) → Claims Specialist at Chubb for 19+ years. Strong.

D**** K****

Paralegal at Morris James LLP

This candidate has direct experience ordering, reviewing, and summarizing medical records as a paralegal in a litigation setting, strongly matching medical review and plaintiff environment, and is located near VA, although the specific PI focus is implied via tort law specialization. Paralegal (Morris James LLP) for 16+ years handling litigation, ordering/reviewing medicals, drafting filings. Strong.

K**** G****

Substitute Teacher-Chesterfield Co. Public Schools

This candidate shows direct experience reviewing medical claims and working with attorneys, aligning with the medical review and legal adjacent aspects, but is currently a substitute teacher and lacks overt PI/plaintiff law firm history. Substitute Teacher → Dalkon Shield Trust (Medical Review/Settlement up to $1M) → Current Substitute Teacher, BS Health Sciences. Strong.

V**** J****

Strong background managing bodily injury claims for insurers, which aligns closely with the skill set needed, but lacks explicit plaintiff law firm or specific Virginia focus other than location. Cincinnati Ins. → Nationwide → Rio National Insurance. Strong.

C*** M****

Senior Resolution Manager at Gallagher Bassett

Strong relevant background in liability and bodily injury claims management, but appears to be defense/insurer side, not plaintiff law firm. Background: GEICO → Vanguard → Broadspire → Gallagher Bassett; Senior role. Strong.

K**** F****

Lead Case Manager at Morgan & Morgan

This person is a Case Manager at a plaintiff personal injury firm and handles PI cases, satisfying three core requirements, though they report supervising others rather than managing individual claims files solely. Morgan & Morgan → varied roles in human services/law support. Strong.

L*** W****

Personal Injury Claims Adjuster/Case Manager at Morgan & Morgan, P.A.

Strong match having worked as a Personal Injury Claims Adjuster/Case Manager in Virginia for 8 years. PI Claims Adjuster/Case Manager at Morgan & Morgan (8+ years, VA experience implied by location). Strong.

J**** D****

Claims Compliance Risk & Training Manager

Experienced claims manager with insurance injury specialist background, local to Virginia, but lacks specific plaintiff/law firm indicator. Background: GEICO → 18+ years at Elephant Insurance (Manager/Supervisor/Specialist); Poli Sci degree. Strong.

K**** M****

This candidate has experience in insurance claims review and medical aspects, and is located within Virginia, though the focus seems more administrative/coding than pure PI case management. Experience: CLRU Claims Specialist at Progressive → Customer service/client associate; currently pursuing healthcare admin degree. Strong.

C**** V***

Examiner.Casualty-Litigation & Complex

Strong experience in casualty/litigation claims includes bodily injury, which aligns well, but the background is entirely defense/insurer-side, not plaintiff. Insurance examiner handling litigation claims across multiple states including DC/MD/WV, closely working with counsel. GEICO → Current role. Strong.

R**** G****

Bodily Injury Specialist

Strong Bodily Injury Specialist experience and explicitly mentions reviewing medical records and billing, suggesting core required elements, but is located outside Virginia. Penn National/Nationwide BI Specialist → Appeals Rep, located in PA. Strong.

L**** L***

Office of the Attorney General

Strong experience in personal injury law as an attorney, suggesting deep knowledge of medical records and PI matters, but title is Assistant Attorney General, not Case Manager. AAG at MD OAG → Principal at own firm (21 yrs) focused on PI/med mal/wrongful death. Strong.

R** R****

CIaims and Litigation Specialist

This candidate has a strong legal background, including being a JD/Attorney and working at a law firm, which strongly suggests familiarity with plaintiff work, and they are located in VA, though their primary recent roles seem to be insurance coverage defense or management rather than active case management/medical review. Senior Claims Specialist, PLPL Claims at Markel (4y 5m) → Claims Manager → Director and Associate at Jackson & Campbell, P.C. (37y 3m) → Attorney. Strong.

M**** B****

Senior Claim Service Analyst at Allstate Insurance Company

Strong relevant experience reviewing medical reports and coordinating litigation defense at an insurance company, suggesting high-level claims handling, though the plaintiff background is missing. Allstate → Seeking Opportunity. Strong.

B**** B****

Global Casualty Claims Specialist

Strong experience adjusting bodily injury claims and negotiating with attorneys across multiple jurisdictions including Virginia, suggesting relevance to PI, though the background is carrier/commercial side rather than plaintiff firm. Career: Project Coordinator → Claims Adjuster (BI) at Allstate/Agency Ins. → Global Casualty Specialist at Under Armour. Strong.

M**** G****

Program Analyst

This candidate has direct experience handling disputed liability claims and negotiating bodily injury settlements with attorneys while working at GEICO in Virginia, strongly suggesting PI experience, although not explicitly plaintiff focused. Telephone Claims Representative at GEICO → Auditor → Scrum Master. Strong.

G**** B****

Senior Claim Specialist at National Interstate Insurance Company

This candidate has extensive claims management experience including handling litigation and working with Virginia claims, though the focus seems very heavily on no-fault/PIP. Senior Claims Adjuster → Supervisor → Manager/Specialist in auto liability/no-fault, handling VA claims, 20+ years experience. Strong.

S** L****

Claims Specialist Manager

This individual has significant bodily injury adjuster experience and management, ticking the PI box, but the background is insurer-side, not plaintiff law firm. GEICO Adjuster → Supervisor → Manager, handling BI claims in DC/MD/PA. Strong.

F**** H****

Case Management Manager-CorVel Corporation

This applicant possesses extensive case management, medical/vocational background, and explicitly mentions Workers' Compensation court testimony in Virginia, suggesting high relevance though not exact PI focus. Case Management Manager @CorVel (13 years) → various Certifications (CCM, VA Rehab Provider). Strong.

A**** V****

Claims Specialist I, Casualty Bodily Injury

Strong overlap with insurance claims handling involving liability, legal document editing, and liaising with attorneys, plus includes actual Case Manager experience, though location is NC. Claims Specialist handling BI liability, editing legal documents, consulting with attorneys, 3 years as Case Manager. Strong.

D**** R****

Attorney Represented Bodily Injury Representative

Excellent experience in handling and reviewing medical records for bodily injury claims, primarily from a defense/insurer side rather than plaintiff firm. Progressive → USAA → GEICO, located near VA. Strong.